dear photorapher
i follow strictly rules in b/w photography
(dont go for too dark nor too bright
the rocks around ur work seems so grany and black
and upper left is bright which is not acceptable in b/w photography
thats because u worked with photoshop
if u switch to darkroom printing the result may come differnet than the photoshop does
because in darkroom u will be able to do the dodge and burn style
ur color work is ok so far
the sea level objects are missing i which it has more lights on see floor ...
so i ll go for picture #1 it gave me more meaning than the # 2
wishing u all the best
limur
__________________
Like your body your mind also gets tired so refresh it by wise sayings.